• Green Glow
  • Posts
  • 🌱 Why the Poorer Your Car, the Dirtier Your Air: A Study of Urban Vehicle Emissions 🚗💨

🌱 Why the Poorer Your Car, the Dirtier Your Air: A Study of Urban Vehicle Emissions 🚗💨

Cheaper cars emit significantly more pollution than newer models, worsening air quality in low-income urban areas. Discover the link between vehicle affordability and emissions.

Author

Green Glow
November 16, 2025

Urban air pollution is often blamed on traffic congestion, aging factories, or lack of clean energy policies. But new research suggests there is another, less-discussed driver of the problem: vehicle affordability. A recent study by the University of Birmingham found that cheaper cars emit significantly more harmful pollutants than newer and more expensive vehicles, even when both belong to the same official emission standard category.
In other words — the poorer your car, the dirtier your air.

Table of Contents

The study revealed that vehicle purchase price is a strong predictor of real-world emissions for key pollutants such as:

  • Nitrogen oxides (NOₓ)

  • Nitrogen dioxide (NO₂)

  • Carbon monoxide (CO)

  • Particulate matter (PM)

For example:

  • Cars worth around £5,000 emitted roughly 8.8 grams of NOₓ per liter of fuel

  • Cars valued near £15,000 emitted around 5.6 grams of NOₓ per liter

That means a 36% drop in emissions when vehicle value increases by just £10,000.

Diesel vs Petrol: Which Shows a Bigger Difference?

The emissions gap appeared in both fuel types but was especially pronounced in diesel vehicles.
Diesel cars tended to show sharper improvements in emissions with every additional £1,000 increase in price, suggesting that:

  • Newer and pricier diesel models have more advanced pollution-control technologies

  • Cheaper diesel vehicles degrade faster and release more pollutants under real-world driving conditions

The Social Inequality Side of Air Pollution

This pattern creates a vicious cycle of environmental inequality:

  • Lower-income individuals are more likely to drive older and cheaper cars

  • Older and cheaper cars emit more pollutants

  • Lower-income communities are often located in dense urban areas with high traffic

  • These same communities become the most exposed to the pollution they contribute to

This means the people with the least ability to afford clean vehicles bear the highest health risks from polluted air — including asthma, heart disease, and respiratory illness.

Why Emission Standards Don’t Tell the Full Story

On paper, two vehicles may share the same emission certification (e.g., Euro 5 or Euro 6).
But in reality:

  • Technology performance deteriorates over time

  • Cheaper vehicles often lack advanced pollution controls

  • Maintenance and part degradation widen the emissions gap every year

This highlights a critical flaw in existing regulation:
The current standards measure lab emissions — not real-world conditions.

The Urban Air Quality Consequences

As more drivers choose cheaper second-hand cars to save money, especially during economic downturns, urban pollution becomes:

  • Harder to regulate

  • Unevenly distributed

  • More concentrated in lower-income areas

Cities with outdated public transportation and high dependence on personal vehicles face the greatest risk of intensified pollution inequality.

What Can Be Done? Policy & Practical Solutions

Experts suggest several targeted strategies to break the affordability–pollution cycle:

Challenge

Solution

Older, high-emission vehicles clustered in low-income areas

Government scrappage incentives for low-income car owners

Clean vehicles are too expensive

Tax relief and lower interest financing for hybrid & EV buyers

Pollution hot spots in major cities

Smart congestion charges based on real-world emissions

Lack of maintenance raises emissions

Subsidized diagnostics and repairs for emission control components

Long-term, increasing access to affordable public transport and electric vehicles can dramatically shift the pattern.

A Global Problem With Local Consequences

While the study was UK-based, the trend applies to many regions worldwide — especially in developing economies where:

  • Used car imports dominate

  • Vehicle lifespan is longer

  • Fuel quality and maintenance standards vary

Wherever older, cheaper cars dominate the market, disadvantaged communities unintentionally breathe and produce the most polluted air.

Conclusion

The affordability of a vehicle is no longer just an economic decision — it is a public-health and environmental factor.
The data is clear: older and cheaper cars emit far more harmful pollutants, fueling urban air quality inequality. Combating this issue will not only require stronger regulations but also better support for low-income drivers to access cleaner transportation options.

Cleaner cars shouldn't be a luxury. Clean air shouldn't be either.

FAQs

Do cheaper cars really produce more pollution?

Yes. Research shows that cheaper and older vehicles emit significantly higher levels of nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter — even when they share the same official emission class as newer cars.

Why do older or low-priced cars emit more harmful gases?

Older cars typically have outdated or degraded emission-control systems. Cheaper models may also lack the advanced clean-technology components found in newer or higher-priced vehicles.

Is the emissions gap the same for petrol and diesel vehicles?

No. The emissions gap is stronger in diesel vehicles, where newer and more expensive models tend to include more sophisticated pollution-control systems.

Who suffers the most from pollution caused by cheaper cars?

Low-income urban communities. These areas tend to have more drivers with older vehicles and also face higher exposure to the pollutants, causing disproportionate health impacts.

Aren’t emission standards like Euro 5 or Euro 6 enough to control pollution?

Not completely. Two cars with the same certification can perform very differently in real-world driving. Age, maintenance, and original vehicle quality strongly affect emissions.

You May Also Like

Sponsored Links